Interesting article ‘Going Dutch’ by author Russell Shorto on his stay in the Netherlands, comparing some aspects of Dutch culture and economics to what he’s used to in the U.S. He was initially disturbed by a certain number…
For the first few months I was haunted by a number: 52. It reverberated in my head; I felt myself a prisoner trying to escape its bars. For it represents the rate at which the income I earn, as a writer and as the director of an institute, is to be taxed. To be plain: more than half of my modest haul, I learned on arrival, was to be swallowed by the Dutch welfare state.
But as he stays longer and gets a better sense of how things compare, it starts to sting a little less…
While the top income-tax rate in the United States is 35 percent, the numbers are a bit misleading. “People coming from the U.S. to the Netherlands focus on that difference, and on that 52 percent,” said Constanze Woelfle, an American accountant based in the Netherlands whose clients are mostly American expats. “But consider that the Dutch rate includes social security, which in the U.S. is an additional 6.2 percent. Then in the U.S. you have state and local taxes, and much higher real estate taxes. If you were to add all those up, you would get close to the 52 percent.”
And he finds some clear advantages to the Dutch system.
In the United States, for a family of four, I paid about $1,400 a month for a policy that didn’t include dental care and was so filled with co-pays, deductibles and exceptions that I routinely found myself replaying in my mind the Monty Python skit in which the man complains about his insurance claim and the agent says, “In your policy it states quite clearly that no claim you make will be paid.” A similar Dutch policy, by contrast, cost 300 euros a month (about $390), with no co-pays, and included dental coverage; about 90 percent of the cost of my daughter’s braces was covered.
Shorto covers much more ground than simply taxes and health insurance… well worth a read to get a sense of some of the unique aspects of the Dutch system – it’s not a simple matter of direct government control. And some things really are just culturally different; examining other cultures can help you see what’s special about your own.